FANDOM


  • This is Menma Uzumaki vs alive Itachi. Menma has access to Obito's MS abilities and Itachi has TB and YM. Menma is limited to two minutes of continuous intangibility and regular kamui speed. Itachi's TB and YM are strictly considered to, seal individuals that only the tip pierces and only block attack's in one direction respectively. They are to be considered as physically a sword and shield.

    Fair fights, no plot armor.

    Who would win and why?

      Loading editor
    • Itachi would win her since he has Totsuka Blade and Yata Mirror. Again,he would put Menma in Tsukuyomi and it said that only a Sasuke can break out of Tsukuyomi but I think Itachi let Sasuke get out. Itachi is far smarter than Menma.What about Amaterasu? Surely,Menma can’t dodge that either.Lots of ways Itachi could win against Menma.

        Loading editor
    • TB is just a sword and YM just a shield. Menma can break out of Tsukuyomi thanks to the black Kurama. Can sharingan genjutsu be cast on someone who wears a mask like that? Amaterasu can be dealt with the repulsion technique. Don't forget kamui is in play as well.

        Loading editor
    • any particular reason why Menma has Obito's MS?

        Loading editor
    • None in particular, but at one point Memna did posses it.

      P.S. Actually, Menma needed a few more jutsus for a discussion.

        Loading editor
    • Itachi finishes him off with super charged Tsukuyomi?

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: TB is just a sword and YM just a shield. Menma can break out of Tsukuyomi thanks to the black Kurama. Can sharingan genjutsu be cast on someone who wears a mask like that? Amaterasu can be dealt with the repulsion technique. Don't forget kamui is in play as well.

      Well,then if your gonna say that,Itachi would still win with Izanami. Izanami can be cast on any shinobi,with eyesight or not. Another way,he can win is with Yasaka Magatama. Itachi takes this.

        Loading editor
    • ^How though? Izanami is literally the last resort Itachi would have. Would it even work on Menma? How would Yasaka Magatama allow Itachi to win?

      Spiraling-ring can overpower any jutsu Itachi can throw.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^How though? Izanami is literally the last resort Itachi would have. Would it even work on Menma? How would Yasaka Magatama allow Itachi to win?

      Spiraling-ring can overpower any jutsu Itachi can throw.

      Your underestimating Itachi too much. Izanami would be the way to Itachi's victory here.By the way,you know when Killer Bee,Naruto and Itachi were going to get locked up in Chibaku Tensei,Itachi said,'Use your strongest long-rage jutsu' Itachi used Yasaka Magatama (which he called it Yasaka Beads) meaning it's his strongest long-range Jutsu. Another way he could win.Healthy Itachi is a major ass threat to anyone.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^How though? Izanami is literally the last resort Itachi would have. Would it even work on Menma? How would Yasaka Magatama allow Itachi to win?

      Spiraling-ring can overpower any jutsu Itachi can throw.

      Wait a minute MEnma is Kurama's jinchuriki?

        Loading editor
    • ^Not sure how to respond to that question.

      @Naruto10647

      I'm asking how. You just reposted what you already stated. Yasaka Magatama may be Itachi's most powerful long range jutsu, but how powerful exactly? Regular spiraling-ring has the same destructive power as a Rasenshuriken. While the great spiraling-ring can destroy Konoha. Really no contest there.

      How do you think the fight will proceed?

        Loading editor
    • It's tough to say. Menma can destroy a village that holds over fourteen thousand people with a single technique. Where as Itachi has a Susano'o equipped with a sword that can cut through almost anything and seal whatever the tip hits, and a shield that protects it from all nature attacks. This includes the Yin and Yang natures, since they are stated to be natures. Even then/ Sasuke was able to disrupt Kurama's connection to Naruto in an instant before he even unlocked Mangekyo. Obito was able to control Kurama. Itachi's a Genjutsu mastermind. I don't see why he can't just point his finger, trap the guy in a Genjutsu to distract him momentarily, conjure his Susano'o, and pierce the guy before he breaks free.

        Loading editor
    • ^Kamui?

      Also, Itachi is not gonna immediately use his Susanoo and all related abilities. Black Kurama is there to help with Genjutsu.

      How do you think the fight will proceed?

      P.S. Surprised you are back, @LoneNinja.

        Loading editor
    • Menma has Kamui? I don't recall that. But that might change things.

      In all likeliness though this would most likely be the scenario.

      Scenario: Itachi and Menma would meet on the battlefield with no knowledge of who they were fighting. They know they must kill each other for whatever reasons. Itachi reveals his red hues to Menma and traps him in his Sharingan: Genjutsu due to him having no reasons not to look. I would like to believe Kurama could help him here, but due to the fact Yagura's Tailed Beast could not help him break free from Genjutsu, and he had complete mastery over it; I don't see how Kurama could help Menma. Especially since Yagura was manipulated by Obito's Sharingan: Genjutsu which controlled him for years and his tailed beast could not do anything to help him. With that in mind, Menma would have to break free on his own. But if Obito was capable of controlling Yagura with it, despite not specializing in Genjutsu; Itachi should have no problems in controlling Menma. If someone can show me a way Menma can break free and explain why Yagura could not do the same, then I'll continue the battle scenario passed this point. Until then, Itachi has the victory.

        Loading editor
    • Itachi isn't Obito and we don't know why Obito's genjutsu was so effective on Yagura. And with the Sharingan and MS, I'm sure Menma can fight off any non-kinjutsu Genjutsu Itachi has. Gyuki broke Bee out of the Genjutsu Sasuke put him in and he is a perfect jinchiriki. Don't just assume Itachi will win based solely on his Genjutsu prowess. Menma was soloing other Jinchiriki like playthings. I'm positive Menma can take Itachi based on what we've seen.

        Loading editor
    • @NinjaofWar
      Actually i was first confused about who this guy was, I thoght that this guy was menma from Ten-Ten's dream.

      Princeharris1993 wrote: Itachi isn't Obito and we don't know why Obito's genjutsu was so effective on Yagura. And with the Sharingan and MS, I'm sure Menma can fight off any non-kinjutsu Genjutsu Itachi has. Gyuki broke Bee out of the Genjutsu Sasuke put him in and he is a perfect jinchiriki. Don't just assume Itachi will win based solely on his Genjutsu prowess. Menma was soloing other Jinchiriki like playthings. I'm positive Menma can take Itachi based on what we've seen.

      The key point here is that jinchuriki has to break the genjutsu, in the fight with Killer Bee neither Bee nor Gyuki realize that they are in Genjutsu. It's only when Itachi gives the clue about being Genjutsu that Gyuki breaks the Genjutsu. Time Dilation is strong Suite of Tsukuyomi so such difference in breaking the Genjutsu could cause the opponent the fight.

        Loading editor
    • actual fight with no extreme hax? menma. with all hax? itachi

        Loading editor
    • LoneNinja
      LoneNinja removed this reply because:
      For some reason it has this scroll bar on one of the messages and it won't go away.
      04:14, February 8, 2018
      This reply has been removed
    • @PrinceofHarris

      When exactly did Gyuki break Bee out of Genjutsu? And you're exactly right. Itachi isn't Obito. Itachi is better than Obito in Genjutsu. Obito rarely used Genjutsu except to control people. If his Genjutsu was more powerful than Itachi's, I'm sure he would of used it constantly in the war especially on the enemies. Itachi is one of the best in Genjutsu, Obito isn't really up there. So if you can provide me a reference as to how Bee escaped the Genjutsu and explain why Yagura could not do the same, then I will continue with the scenario that I believe would happen. Also instead of everyone saying "Menma wins" describe a scenario as to how he wins, or else it's just words.

      Namikazenaruto9 wrote: The key point here is that jinchuriki has to break the genjutsu, in the fight with Killer Bee neither Bee nor Gyuki realize that they are in Genjutsu. It's only when Itachi gives the clue about being Genjutsu that Gyuki breaks the Genjutsu. Time Dilation is strong Suite of Tsukuyomi so such difference in breaking the Genjutsu could cause the opponent the fight.

      If this is also true, then I stand firmly in believing Itachi wins by the scenario I provided since Kurama (A Tailed Beast who has been controlled countless times by the Sharingan) isn't likely to sense being in the Genjutsu and help Menma break free. Also can anyone provide me a reference to Menma using Obito's abilities?

        Loading editor
    • Gyuki broke Bee out of Sasuke's MS genjutsu and broke Bee out of edo Itachi's genjutsu before his shuriken got close. In the Sasuke vs Bee instance, Bee explained how genjutsu is useless to a perfect Jinchuriki.

      Furthermore, Menma has the nine masked beasts. This according to Chiyo's words, multiple allies can overcome sharingan genjutsu, makes effective genjutsu quite unlikely. Plus, Menma has unrestricted access to Black Kurama's power, meaning if his chakra is disturbed by genjutsu, he can easily reset his chakra with Kurama's chakra. In addition, Menma has Obito's MS, which can see through genjutsu and was powerful enough to control Kurama and Yagura.

      Considering all of this, Itachi's genjutsu would be highly ineffective.

      Scenario: Itachi and Menma face off. Itachi throws his kunai at Menma, which Menma using telekinesis stops. Menma unleashes the nine masked beasts. This makes sharingan genjutsu effectively useless. Itachi manages to dodge the beasts' attacks and starts using elemental ninjutsu.

      Menma would then switch to spiraling-ring and hurl it at Itachi, Itachi would obviously dodge, but his ninjutsu would be overpowered. Itachi would prepare Amaterasu at this point, with Menma and the nine masked beasts staring him down.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      After re-reading the war arc, I come to the realization that Bee was in fact effected by Itachi's Genjutsu and Gyuki did not break him free. In fact it wasn't until they realized it was Genjutsu when he was replaced by crows and he warned them. Reference = Itachi and Nagato vs Naruto and Bee. Also Itachi usually starts off with Sharingan active and a Genjutsu attack right off the back. Nearly every fight he starts off with Genjutsu, so the scenario you provided doesn't fit his style. So the scenario is:

      Itachi and Menma would meet on the battlefield with no knowledge of who they were fighting. They know they must kill each other for whatever reasons. Itachi reveals his red hues to Menma and traps him in his Sharingan: Genjutsu due to him having no reasons not to look.

      Menma doesn't just go full on Nine-tails off the back to just anyone. So there isn't a reason it'd be his second move, so the multiple enemy thing, isn't a likely scenario. Now I tried finding the chapter where Bee stated Genjutsu is ineffective to him (Which would be a contradiction since Itachi did get him later on during the war), but I cannot find it, can you provide it for me? Also that statement is kind of bull since Yagura was a perfect Jinchuriki but was controlled by Obito's Genjutsu, a lesser Genjutsu user.

        Loading editor
    • So, you are giving Itachi prep? Why?

      Gyuki clearly breaks Bee twice out of Sharingan genjutsu. Reference is, Sasuke vs Bee and Naruto and Bee vs Itachi and Nagato. So don't know what you're talking about.

      Menma knows about the Uchiha and their abilities. Furthermore, he has Obito's MS in this case, he isn't gonna be surprised that Itachi is gonna use his Sharingan. I've used multiple points to show that sharingan genjutsu is, for all intensive purposes useless in this fight. Also, is Menma's eyes even visible due to his mask?

      Menma always uses the nine masked beasts in his fights, so why are you saying he won't use it?

      Obito controlling Yagura seems to be plot, since what was the point of controlling Kirikagure? It's not mentioned how useful it was to his plans.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: So, you are giving Itachi prep? Why?

      Gyuki clearly breaks Bee twice out of Sharingan genjutsu. Reference is, Sasuke vs Bee and Naruto and Bee vs Itachi and Nagato. So don't know what you're talking about.
      Really.
      A Jinchuriki isn't immune to Genjutsu, they can get out of one very easily. Also if you would observe ITachi Vs Bee fight, Neither Gyuki nor Bee know that they are in Genjutsu until Itachi actually tells them. So Menma would probably die in Genjutsu.
        Loading editor
    • A Jinchurki isn’t immune to Genjutsu. If you think about Itachi vs Naruto (I think episode 15 in Shippuden), Itachi raised one finger and Naruto was under Genjutsu. And yet the fact that he had Nine Tails inside him,he still didn’t break it. Also when Itachi landed Tsukuyomi on Kakashi,Kakashi had to stay in the hospital,Correct me if I’m wrong. Itachi takes this. I’ve said this multiple times and yet the one who created this thread doesn’t understand.

        Loading editor
    • ^You're quite mistaken. Itachi vs Naruto, Naruto was not a perfect Jinchuriki at that point. From Sasuke vs Bee, Bee clearly states why genjutsu is not effective when you have a partner to break you out of it. So no, what you said is not happening.

      You are forgetting that Menma also has Obito's MS and has unrestricted access to black Kurama's chakra. Menma not gonna get caught in regular sharingan genjutsu for sure. Menma also has Uzumaki stamina and Kurama's healing ability, he not Kakashi.

      I think the user above doesn't understand lol. Try reading above.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^You're quite mistaken. Itachi vs Naruto, Naruto was not a perfect Jinchuriki at that point. From Sasuke vs Bee, Bee clearly states why genjutsu is not effective when you have a partner to break you out of it. So no, what you said is not happening.

      You are forgetting that Menma also has Obito's MS and has unrestricted access to black Kurama's chakra. Menma not gonna get caught in regular sharingan genjutsu for sure. Menma also has Uzumaki stamina and Kurama's healing ability, he not Kakashi.

      I think the user above doesn't understand lol. Try reading above.

      Finally understand you. So Menma has Obito’s MS abilities,right? Menma gives Itachi a damn hard time and then Itachi activates his Susano’o and raises one finger,traps him in a genjutsu and Itachi cuts him with his sword by the time Menma would’ve got out.

        Loading editor
    • ^Don't think genjutsu on that level will work on Menma, but thanks for the mini-rundown.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^Don't think genjutsu on that level will work on Menma, but thanks for the mini-rundown.

      If I remember correctly despite Kurama's cooperation Naruto actually falls for Genjutsu in the movie. In fact Kurama clearly states that it's over if he looks into his eyes.

        Loading editor
    • Namikazenaruto9 wrote: If I remember correctly despite Kurama's cooperation Naruto actually falls for Genjutsu in the movie. In fact Kurama clearly states that it's over if he looks into his eyes.

      Not only is that non-canon (which, now that I think about it, doesn't really matter much in this particular thread), Naruto wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that time

        Loading editor
    • UltimaDude wrote:

      Namikazenaruto9 wrote: If I remember correctly despite Kurama's cooperation Naruto actually falls for Genjutsu in the movie. In fact Kurama clearly states that it's over if he looks into his eyes.

      Not only is that non-canon (which, now that I think about it, doesn't really matter much in this particular thread), Naruto wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that time

      Cannon , Non Canon Seriously? We are talking about non canon character and now you are bringing that up?
      Kurama willingly gives complete cooperation in the movie for just that once.
        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      "I've used multiple points to show that sharingan genjutsu is, for all intensive purposes useless in this fight." Incorrect. You used the fight Nagato and Itachi vs Naruto and Bee. This doesn't work merely for the fact that Bee and Gyuki did not realize they were in Genjutsu until Itachi warned them and they seen the crows. This actually counters your statement. Yes Gyuki can free Bee from Genjutsu, but it does not detect when it's in it unless it's plainly obvious.

      "So, you are giving Itachi prep? Why?" What did I give Itachi before the fight? Nothing. I merely stated he starts off with his Sharingan merely due to the fact there hasn't been a single fight he doesn't start off with it since joining the Akatsuki.

      "Menma always uses the nine masked beasts in his fights, so why are you saying he won't use it?" Incorrect. I never stated he wouldn't use it at all, I just stated based off all his fights, it wouldn't be his second move.

      "Menma also has Obito's MS" Can you provide a source to Menma using Obito's Ms? Or did you give him it to give him a fighting chance?

      With that being said. My scenario basically proves Itachi wins with a glance with no plot armor to save Menma. It's highly likely Itachi can control Menma with the Genjutsu just as Obito did with Yagura.

        Loading editor
    • ^I'm afraid you are incorrect. After re-reading the manga, in the instance of Itachi vs Bee. After Bee 'caught' Itachi with his tentacle, and Itachi dispersed into crows, Bee said, that Itachi was an illusion. After that, Itachi said, Bee shouldn't look into his eyes directly. And then Gyuki broke him out of the genjutsu, so no, my point stands firm.

      I meant that Itachi can't start the fight with his sharingan already active. But, either way, Menma won't be affected by normal sharingan genjutsu. Re-watch road to a Ninja for the reference to Obito's MS. And I already explained why I gave Menma Obito's MS.

      How can Itachi control Menma, when Obito's MS can see through genjutsu and Kurama can break him out of it? Also, don't give feats of Obito to Itachi.

      You haven't proven Itachi wins, just that you think he does, despite my points.

        Loading editor
    • Namikazenaruto9 wrote: Cannon , Non Canon Seriously? We are talking about non canon character and now you are bringing that up?
      Kurama willingly gives complete cooperation in the movie for just that once.

      How did you miss the part where I said, "which, now that I think about it, doesn't really matter much in this particular thread". Reading comprehension, use it.

      Also, Naruto still wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that time, otherwise he would have had Kurama Mode and Tailed Beast Mode. Even if you can consider Naruto a temporary perfect jinchuriki, the "Tailed Beast breaking out their jinchuriki from genjutsu" thing happened before the events of the movie, therefore Kurama's statement is null and void.

      You have two options:
      A.) Accept that Naruto wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that moment in the movie
      or
      B.) Disregard Kurama's statement because it's non-canon and contradicts the manga

        Loading editor
    • tsukuyomi is not normal genjutsu so black kurama is helpless.

        Loading editor
    • "Itachi dispersed into crows, Bee said, that Itachi was an illusion. After that, Itachi said, Bee shouldn't look into his eyes directly. And then Gyuki broke him out of the genjutsu" Did I not say that? "In fact it wasn't until they realized it was Genjutsu when he was replaced by crows and he warned them." /AND/ "Bee and Gyuki did not realize they were in Genjutsu until Itachi warned them and they seen the crows." I did. So how am I incorrect? I clearly stated they didn't know it was Genjutsu until they seen the crows. In fact, Bee was trapped in the Genjutsu before he even grabbed Itachi with the tentacle due to him looking into his eyes which Itachi then states not to do for future references after they seen the crows.

      "so no, my point stands firm." Actually it doesn't since they didn't break out until they noticed they were in Genjutsu. They needed to see Itachi's crows before realizing they were in Genjutsu. Gyuki did nothing until after Itachi said something, thus he didn't even know. My argument is the one that stands firm.

      "Re-watch road to a Ninja for the reference to Obito's MS. And I already explained why I gave Menma Obito's MS." Uhh. No. I don't want to watch a movie to find out lol. I just read the site's run down of what happened. After reading it, I've learned that it was Obito in Menma's body, not Menma possessing it. After Obito leaves, he no longer has it. So the thread should be Obito in Menma's body vs Itachi. But that doesn't really matter.

      "Also, don't give feats of Obito to Itachi." Which feat did I give Itachi that Obito did? Controlling people via Genjutsu? Itachi was stated to be able to control people via Genjutsu, 4th war, reveal of white Zetsu transforming into people, chapter 540. Also Itachi > Obito in Genjutsu. Itachi also possesses the Genjutsu Obito used. So... if Itachi has the jutsu, has the ability, has the skill, then he can do it?

      "How can Itachi control Menma, when Obito's MS can see through genjutsu and Kurama can break him out of it?" Now that I know he has Obito's Mangekyo for sure, you make a good point. But just cause he has Sharingan, doesn't mean he can detect when he's in Genjutsu. I mean, the whole "See through Genjutsu" thing was abandon a long time ago. It was even remove from this wiki. The reason being, those with Sharingan, being caught in Genjutsu without knowing such as Sasuke and Kakashi. Since this is Menma, he won't have mastered the eye which makes him as good with Sharingan as a Genin Sasuke, unless you can prove Menma can wield the Sharingan more proficiently than Genin Sasuke, which you can't cause Menma has never used it, Obito in his body did. But I'll bite.

      Scenario continues: Menma is trapped in the Genjutsu. Somehow he discerns he is in one. Kurama free's him, but by the time he comes to, Itachi who had already detected Kurama's presence such as Sasuke did with the Sharingan when he first saw Kurama, is already there trying to stab his neck.

      Even if he can discern he is in Genjutsu, he doesn't break it instantly. That's all the time Itachi needs since they were within visual range of each other. And we seen how fast Itachi is when he wants to be, granted that was sick Itachi so this Itachi isn't limited physically. So the question now is, can you prove Menma can detect and break the Genjutsu before Itachi moves a few feet to stab his throat?

        Loading editor
    • ^Bee already knew it was genjutsu when Itachi dispersed into crows. Hence the words, "An illusion". Itachi said that Bee shouldn't look directly into his eyes, for further combat. Gyuki broke him out. Itachi's help wasn't needed. So yeah, my point does stand firm.

      What genjutsu did Obito use to control Yagura? And how does Itachi know this genjutsu?

      Sharingan can see through genjutsu, it's one of it's base abilities. MS more so. It's unlikely anyone with an MS is gonna be caught by regular sharingan genjutsu.

      Scenario continues: Itachi faces off against Menma and the nine masked beasts. Itachi tries to one-shot Menma with Amaterasu, which then gets blocked by the repulsion technique. Itachi realizes this and tries to stream Amaterasu to the beasts. He manages to burn three of the beasts but the others attack him. While dodging, Itachi sees another spiraling-ring launched at him.

      He dodges but his cloak is gone and is suffering backlash from Amaterasu.

      So the question now is, what is Itachi's next move?

      P.S. I have answered your question in the text above, however I see you are ignoring the fact that Menma has unrestricted access to black Kurama's chakra, why is that?

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^Bee already knew it was genjutsu when Itachi dispersed into crows. Hence the words, "An illusion". Itachi said that Bee shouldn't look directly into his eyes, for further combat. Gyuki broke him out. Itachi's help wasn't needed. So yeah, my point does stand firm.

      What genjutsu did Obito use to control Yagura? And how does Itachi know this genjutsu?

      Sharingan can see through genjutsu, it's one of it's base abilities. MS more so. It's unlikely anyone with an MS is gonna be caught by regular sharingan genjutsu.

      Scenario continues: Itachi faces off against Menma and the nine masked beasts. Itachi tries to one-shot Menma with Amaterasu, which then gets blocked by the repulsion technique. Itachi realizes this and tries to stream Amaterasu to the beasts. He manages to burn three of the beasts but the others attack him. While dodging, Itachi sees another spiraling-ring launched at him.

      He dodges but his cloak is gone and is suffering backlash from Amaterasu.

      So the question now is, what is Itachi's next move?

      P.S. I have answered your question in the text above, however I see you are ignoring the fact that Menma has unrestricted access to black Kurama's chakra, why is that?

      I dont think Obito controlled Yagura under Genjutsu. Kabuto probably controlled Yagura with Edo Tensei.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      "Itachi said that Bee shouldn't look directly into his eyes, for further combat. Gyuki broke him out. Itachi's help wasn't needed. So yeah, my point does stand firm." How does this prove Bee and Gyuki together know when they are in Genjutsu? Itachi and Bee make eye contact and Bee got caught in Genjutsu. Bee gets behind Itachi and uses tentacle to catch him. Itachi then disperses into crows revealing Bee is in a Genjutsu. Bee states "Illusion". Itachi warns Bee. Gyuki nags Bee. Gyuki frees Bee. This basically says from the moment eye contact was made to when Bee states "Illusion" Bee and Gyuki had no idea they were in a Genjutsu. So how does that prove they can detect Genjutsu? Just so you know, my argument was never about Bee and Gyuki not being able to break out of Genjutsu, I actually agreed up above that they could. My argument is they won't know they're in one.

      "Sharingan can see through genjutsu, it's one of it's base abilities. MS more so. It's unlikely anyone with an MS is gonna be caught by regular sharingan genjutsu." Uhh no it doesn't. Sure at one point in the story that was said, but not anymore. That was changed even in the Databook, it's now to discern Chakra. The reason being too many Genjutsu have worked on Sharingan users without them knowing. They can, with enough skill discern when they're in Genjutsu, sure. But Menma? No LOL. Not someone who has never used it before. Especially against Itachi's who has fooled many Sharingan users. But even if he did have the skill to detect when he is in Genjutsu, scroll down to my scenario.

      "What genjutsu did Obito use to control Yagura? And how does Itachi know this genjutsu?" Maybe the only Genjutsu Obito is listed in having (Minus Izanagi and Infinite Tsukyomi for obvious reasons)? Sharingan: Genjutsu. Itachi is listed a user, so ask the Databook, Manga, and Kishimoto.

      "Scenario continues: Itachi faces off against Menma and the nine masked beasts." Why does Menma have them out? Did you give him prep time now? You must really want him to win, lol. You also neglected to answer my scenario and completely ignored it, thus meaning Menma gets stabbed in the neck and dies, until you give a counter as to how Menma detects Genjutsu, breaks it, detects Itachi, and reacts before Itachi who was a few feet away from him, stabs him in the throat. Itachi is shown to be insanely fast so do not underestimate his speed. He was shown to be able to move faster than most Jonin could follow.

      "P.S. I have answered your question in the text above, however I see you are ignoring the fact that Menma has unrestricted access to black Kurama's chakra, why is that?" You didn't answer all my questions. Also, I didn't disagree with it so I didn't address it, never stated Menma couldn't use Kurama's Chakra. Still doesn't matter. Menma still has to discern, break, and react. Sharingan doesn't break you out of Genjutsu. Only can discern it.

      P.s. You still have yet to prove Menma has the knowledge on how to use a Mangekyo Sharingan. It took Kakashi a decade before he was able to use his Mangekyo despite having it unlocked already. You also have yet to prove Menma can utilize it more sufficient than a Genin Sasuke Uchiha.

        Loading editor
    • LoneNinja wrote:

      Itachi also possesses the Genjutsu Obito used. So... if Itachi has the jutsu, has the ability, has the skill, then he can do it?

      Even if he can discern he is in Genjutsu, he doesn't break it instantly. That's all the time Itachi needs since they were within visual range of each other. And we seen how fast Itachi is when he wants to be, granted that was sick Itachi so this Itachi isn't limited physically. So the question now is, can you prove Menma can detect and break the Genjutsu before Itachi moves a few feet to stab his throat?

      My argument is that anything lower than MS-level genjutsu is unlikely to work on Menma. And you said Itachi had to tell Bee that he was in a genjutsu, which didn't happen. That's why I had to explain it to you.

      What is your basis for, "Sharingan seeing through genjutsu" not working? When has Itachi fooled Sharingan users with regular genjutsu? On the genjutsu Obito used on Yagura, you said Itachi can use it. So what is the name of that genjutsu and how did Itachi learn it? You stated it, so you please answer. You have to back up your points.

      Don't act like you can't read, the scenario continues from my previous one above. I showed you why sharingan genjutsu would be useless, so I kinda ruined your rundown. Since all it had was, "Itachi uses sharingan genjutsu."

      P.S. Menma has instant access to Kurama's chakra, so if he is caught in a genjutsu, he can instantly break out. Also, he has exceptional chakra control, due to the fact of him being able to craft the nine masked beasts(living entities) out of Kurama's chakra.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: So, you are giving Itachi prep? Why?

      Gyuki clearly breaks Bee twice out of Sharingan genjutsu. Reference is, Sasuke vs Bee and Naruto and Bee vs Itachi and Nagato. So don't know what you're talking about.

      Menma knows about the Uchiha and their abilities. Furthermore, he has Obito's MS in this case, he isn't gonna be surprised that Itachi is gonna use his Sharingan. I've used multiple points to show that sharingan genjutsu is, for all intensive purposes useless in this fight. Also, is Menma's eyes even visible due to his mask?

      Menma always uses the nine masked beasts in his fights, so why are you saying he won't use it?

      Obito controlling Yagura seems to be plot, since what was the point of controlling Kirikagure? It's not mentioned how useful it was to his plans.

      Obito has mangekyo Sharingan

      mangekyo Sharingan has the power to control a bijuu

      Obito as a revenge on mist cast a genjutsu on yagura for killing rin

      Usually a genjutsu cast on a jinchuriki is negated by bijuu sealed within him/her

      But obito cast a genjutsu on sanbi and then yagura hence he was able to maintain his genjutsu. Or He used the sharingan:genjutsu jutsu.

      This is a jutsu granted to all users of the sharingan, its one of the most versatile genjutsu and could be used in many ways. Obito was skilled enough to control kurama with his mangekyo sharingan, he was probably skilled enough to use a genjutsu that could last for a really long time. Either one of those. We never know. Also,both Gyuki and Bee didnt know they were in a genjutsu till Itachi dispersed his crows and warned both. That is when Gyuki broke Bee out of Genjutsu. You really want Menma to win,lol. Also,Izanami is hax like Kotoamtsukami. It can be cast on anyone,with eyesight or not,or with Tailed Beast or not. In other cases,it is an infinite loop. You simply cannot escape it unless you accept yourself. I am saying this because a Jinchuuriki has never escaped Izanami before and it has only been used on Kabuto.

        Loading editor
    • ^That paragraph can be summed up by saying, you don't know what genjutsu Obito used and you deny what happened in the instance of Itachi vs Bee. Gotcha.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^That paragraph can be summed up by saying, you don't know what genjutsu Obito used and you deny what happened in the instance of Itachi vs Bee. Gotcha.

      Your ignoring my statement completely. Again I say,Itachi warned them that it was a genjutsu. Gyuki broke Bee out of the genjutsu.

        Loading editor
    • Nice edit though, so what was your point again?

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: Nice edit though, so what was your point again?

      It is so clear that you are avoiding my Izanami statement. I want you to show me how he would counter Izanami.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja Of War

      "My argument is that anything lower than MS-level genjutsu is unlikely to work on Menma." But you aren't 100% sure that's the case, so I can't believe your statement if you, yourself have doubt.

      "When has Itachi fooled Sharingan users with regular genjutsu?" There are a few instances. Sasuke vs Itachi is a good one. Though they do eventually recognize it's Genjutsu, they were still temporarily caught in it.

      "On the genjutsu Obito used on Yagura, you said Itachi can use it. So what is the name of that genjutsu and how did Itachi learn it? You stated it, so you please answer. You have to back up your points." I did state it, what? Genjutsu: Sharingan. It's the only Genjutsu out of three that Obito has that controls people. It should also be noted in Chapter 501, Obito was able to use this Genjutsu to control the Tailed beast inside a Jinchuriki after the Jinchuriki looked into his eyes. It's one of the most basic Sharingan techniques, even Kakashi had it.

      "Don't act like you can't read, the scenario continues from my previous one above." Actually I posted my scenario first so I don't have to address yours. Especially since you start Itachi off with a Shuriken attack when 95% of his fights, he starts off with Genjutsu.

      "so I kinda ruined your rundown" You didn't. You just state, Menma breaks out instantly cause he has Obito's Mangekyo and has Kurama reserves, lol. No one has been shown ever to break out instantly from Genjutsu they get caught in. That's just a made up ability you are giving him.

      "if he is caught in a genjutsu" He would be. There'd be no reason for him not to look in Itachi's eyes, unless you are giving them absolute knowledge on each other. I never denied he could break out either. I just merely stated by the time he did, Itachi would already cut his throat due to his speed and the distance between them.

        Loading editor
    • @Naruto10647

      You clearly avoided my statement, but I'll indulge you.

      Izanami requires a lot of prep. According to this wiki, Izanami is cast through physical sensations shared between the user and the target. Now, for Itachi to cast it, he'll have to set up some scenario and then somehow make physical contact with Menma. There are a few problems to this:

      1) Menma obviously has the nine masked beasts, and they are not gonna stand idle while Itachi is busy with some jutsu. They won't let up, and Itachi is gonna have his hands full. Furthermore, Menma is probably gonna be throwing rasen-rings all day. Itachi doesn't have time to prep in that case.

      2) In some far fetch scenario, Itachi manages to prep and goes in to make physical contact. Menma has Obito's MS and the ability to phase through anything. Itachi won't be able to make physical contact with Menma in that case.

      3) Menma can use the repulsion technique to repel Itachi if he gets close. From anywhere on his person.

      4) Izanami is a glorified Uchiha talk no jutsu. It's designed to make the target accept who they are. Not for combat. Also, would it even work on Menma, does he accept who he is? This fight is also a death battle, Itachi's motives are not to 'save' Menma. He doesn't know anything about Menma why would he want to save him? Does he know it would work?

      So, what was your point again?

        Loading editor
    • TSUKUYOMI is enough for itachi to win.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      It’s clear that you are a Menma fanboy. I already said that Itachi would activate his Susano’o and then trap him in a genjutsu and by the time he is out,Itachi would’ve killed him. This would happen because of the distance and Itachi’s speed.

        Loading editor
    • ^I'm a fanboy for dismantling your point? Good one lol.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^I'm a fanboy for dismantling your point? Good one lol.

      No,your a fanboy because your literally wanting Menma to win and denying all our solid statement and proof.

        Loading editor
    • ^Except you are the one denying my post about Izanami. And acting out lol.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^Except you are the one denying my post about Izanami. And acting out lol.

      I answered all your questions about Izanami.

        Loading editor
    • ^Um no...

      Let me tell you why you lost this argument. You could have argued against my points or scenario. Instead you chose to ask me why Izanami won't work, which I answered in full. This answer apparently upset you so much, you decided to call me a fanboy.

      You literally could not construct any reasonable answer, so you resorted to name calling. You lost all credibility on this thread.

      P.S. You didn't answer anything on Izanami.

      @LoneNinja

      It's obvious we don't agree on the genjutsu point. I just can't understand why you think regular genjutsu will have any effect on these two. But not gonna argue further, since it is pointless.

      Sasuke vs Itachi wasn't an example of fooling someone with regular genjutsu. Both Itachi and Sasuke were standing still and only using genjutsu on each other. No-one was fooled in combat. Black zetsu even commented that they were just feeling each other out with genjutsu.

      So where is the proof that indeed that is the technique Obito uses on Yagura? Show me in the manga where it is stated. Once again, your scenario is quite thin. All it has is Itachi uses genjutsu. Nothing else. So it isn't a scenario.

      Ignoring everything in my points might seem fun, but when looking at all these things, it does paint a very different picture.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^Um no...

      Let me tell you why you lost this argument. You could have argued against my points or scenario. Instead you chose to ask me why Izanami won't work, which I answered in full. This answer apparently upset you so much, you decided to call me a fanboy.

      You literally could not construct any reasonable answer, so you resorted to name calling. You lost all credibility on this thread.

      P.S. You didn't answer anything on Izanami.

      @LoneNinja

      It's obvious we don't agree on the genjutsu point. I just can't understand why you think regular genjutsu will have any effect on these two. But not gonna argue further, since it is pointless.

      Sasuke vs Itachi wasn't an example of fooling someone with regular genjutsu. Both Itachi and Sasuke were standing still and only using genjutsu on each other. No-one was fooled in combat. Black zetsu even commented that they were just feeling each other out with genjutsu.

      So where is the proof that indeed that is the technique Obito uses on Yagura? Show me in the manga where it is stated. Once again, your scenario is quite thin. All it has is Itachi uses genjutsu. Nothing else. So it isn't a scenario.

      Ignoring everything in my points might seem fun, but when looking at all these things, it does paint a very different picture.

      So you are ignoring our points? And the statement didn't upset me at all. You are literally underestimating Itachi's speed.

        Loading editor
    • Naruto10647 wrote: And the statement didn't upset me at all. You are literally underestimating Itachi's speed.

      Your actions say otherwise. I think you have to explain your points. To show that you are not biased.

      I see you sweeping my statement under the rug, why is that?

        Loading editor
    • Well Itachi is in fact very fast, remember that Kakashi couldn't keep up with his handseals and he has Sharingan.

      If you want speed feats, go to the fight Itachi & Nagato vs Killer Bee & Naruto.

        Loading editor
    • Vinuth123 wrote: TSUKUYOMI is enough for itachi to win.

        Loading editor
    • ^Except Kakashi did keep up. He saw the water technique incoming.

      No speed feat in the instance of Itachi and Naruto. Check chapter 548.

        Loading editor
    • UltimaDude wrote: How did you miss the part where I said, "which, now that I think about it, doesn't really matter much in this particular thread". Reading comprehension, use it.

      You dismissed a feat which I mentioned in the previous reply. That's why I even said about Cannon-Non Cannon stuff. It could be good for you to keep track of what others are talking about before blaming others for comprehension problems.

      UltimaDude wrote: Also, Naruto still wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that time, otherwise he would have had Kurama Mode and Tailed Beast Mode. Even if you can consider Naruto a temporary perfect jinchuriki, the "Tailed Beast breaking out their jinchuriki from genjutsu" thing happened before the events of the movie, therefore Kurama's statement is null and void.

      You have two options:
      A.) Accept that Naruto wasn't a perfect jinchuriki at that moment in the movie
      or
      B.) Disregard Kurama's statement because it's non-canon and contradicts the manga

      Granted Naruto wasn't Perfect Jinchuriki. however from Kurama's words you would come to realize that he was giving complete cooperation. He even gave that vital intel. If you really want to void well documented statement backed by previous victims(*cough* Kushina) by all means.
      And those two aren't my only options,
      I could easily go about saying that Perfect Jinchuriki isn't immune to certain genjutsu. Which I Know for a fact is true. And that in this case that Menma guy can be controlled with Genjutsu.(Even Obito controls him with genjutsu after Naruto defeats this guy, So that's the Second evidence against your statements.)
      @Ninja OF War
      When Obito actually controls this Menma guy, Menma is incapable of using his own techniques. He couldn't even unleas Kurama, so I think so this might be more like Obito Vs Itachi?
        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Cause Genjutsu still has effect on Sharingan users. They don't automatically break out.

      Cases: Itachi vs Kakashi, Kakashi's clone got trapped in Genjutsu despite having Sharingan. Sasuke vs Itachi, even if they were testing each other out, they were still trapped in Genjutsu. Sasuke vs Danzo, Danzo was trapped in Genjutsu. Itachi and Sasuke vs Kabuto, both Uchihas were trapped by Tatuyas Flute Genjutsu. And many more. Just cause you have the Sharingan, doesn't mean you are immune to Genjutsu dude.

      "So where is the proof that indeed that is the technique Obito uses on Yagura?" The proof is in the Databook. He only has three Genjutsu's. Infinite Tsukyomi (Needs ten tails). Izanagi (doesn't control people and Obito didn't lose his vision). And Sharingan: Genjutsu, the only Genjutsu he has, stated to control people. Therefore it's Sharingan: Genjutsu. Even if it wasn't, he still used it to control the Kyubi and is able to look a Jinchuriki in the eyes and control the tailed beast inside them. So if Itachi wanted, he can make Kyubi turn on Menma, since he has the skill and jutsu to do so.

      My scenario yet again: Itachi and Menma would meet on the battlefield with no knowledge of who they were fighting. They know they must kill each other for whatever reasons. Itachi reveals his red hues to Menma and traps him and Kurama in his Sharingan: Genjutsu due to him having no reasons not to look. |If Scenario| Menma somehow recognizes he is in Genjutsu, but no longer has access to Kurama's abilities due to Itachi controlling Kurama. So he cannot break free. |Another If Scenario| Menma somehow manages to break free, but by the time he comes to, Itachi already cuts his throat.

        Loading editor
    • ^Kakashi's clone in that instance wasn't affected. It grabbed onto Itachi and Itachi himself commented that his genjutsu was not working. For Itachi vs Sasuke, neither one of them were fooled, so it's not what you said. Danzo was trapped in combat, but Shisui's eye was on cooldown. So it doesn't count.

      In any case, the genjutsu user is also preoccupied with the genjutsu. It's not as cut and dry as you think. I asked for proof and you didn't deliver, so you can't say. Furthermore, it is not acceptable to give Itachi this genjutsu, since there is no basis.

      So you're still clinging to that scenario hey? Not surprised. But, what about Menma's chakra control abilities and Itachi's preoccupation? Not well thought out. Itachi isn't cutting his throat.

      Reminder: Menma has instant access to Black Kurama's chakra. Menma would likely use a well placed repulsion technique on Itachi. Might even cause Itachi's own kunai to slit his own throat.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Kakashi was indeed affected what? Did you not see the clone in the Genjutsu realm as thin as paper and burned alive? If not, then I suggest you re-read or re-watch it. Unless you're making things up, which isn't the first time in your post. Literally your post is made up of taking jutsu Itachi has (In Manga and Databook), away saying he doesn't have them, and placing limitations not stated to be there, lol. Itachi did not say it didn't work, he said it did not work on Kakashi cause it was a clone affected by the Genjutsu. As for Itachi vs Sasuke, they were fooled. Sasuke was fooled enough to stab a chair, so your point there is mute. Even if Danzo's Mangekyo was on cool down, his basic Sharingan wasn't. His Sharingan didn't just disappear from his eye socket, lol. Whenever Kakashi's Mangekyo went on cool down, his eyes reverted back to basic three tomoe. Danzo's Sharingan didn't just magically disappear, so your point there is also mute.

      "In any case, the genjutsu user is also preoccupied with the genjutsu." Where does it state when using Genjutsu: Sharingan, the user is preoccupied? Cause that's the Genjutsu we're talking about. Sasuke was moving pretty fine when he used it on Danzo to think he had an extra Izanagi. In Chapter 15, Kakashi also seemed to move just fine. So another mute point.

      "I asked for proof and you didn't deliver" I did deliver. You just don't want to accept it. If you state it wasn't Genjutsu: Sharingan (The name of the actual Genjutsu), then what was it? If you say it's a different jutsu, then you are giving a jutsu to Obito that he isn't stated to have.

      "Furthermore, it is not acceptable to give Itachi this genjutsu, since there is no basis." Uhh. Itachi sure the hell does have Genjutsu: Sharingan, that was a poor attempt at trying to prove me wrong. He is listed in the Databook in having it. It is also listed that you can control a Tailed Beast, people, and even a tailed beast inside a person, through eye contact. So good game.

      "So you're still clinging to that scenario hey? Not surprised. But, what about Menma's chakra control abilities and Itachi's preoccupation? Not well thought out. Itachi isn't cutting his throat." Sure I am, since you haven't countered anything and keep taking things away from Itachi that he is stated to have, and giving Menma things he doesn't, so Menma could win. At what point does it stop being a debate, and become more about a fan arguing over a character he likes despite being wrong. You're starting to reach there bud, I suggest you stop taking things away from Itachi such as Genjutsu: Sharingan and putting limitations it isn't stated to have on it. And FYI, he is cutting his throat, since Kakashi was able to move in Chapter 15, Itachi can move as well. :]

      Reminder: The moment Itachi and Menma made eye contact, Menma lost access to Kurama's reserves. Menma won't be repulsing anything while inside Genjutsu: Sharingan. His throat will be slit by Itachi.

      Note: If your next reply is placing more limits on a technique not shown or stated to have such limits, or disregarding a technique's abilities stated to have, I won't be replying. You already gave Menma an ability he didn't have since it was Obito in his body, controlling him. At a certain point, it becomes a fan trying arguing over a character he likes despite that character not being able to win. And I don't like to argue, I like challenging debates.

        Loading editor
    • ^LOL

      Kakashi's clone grabbed Itachi. Itachi commentated that his genjutsu wasn't taking effect. I think you need to re-watch lol(ch 260). Don't deny just because you want to. Sasuke and Itachi were both standing still, they were not in combat. If you say they were fooled, then why didn't Sasuke try and stab Itachi in the throat? Danzo's sharingan eye was covered, it was clear that it was not active. Points standing.

      Chiyo's words, multiple allies can overcome sharingan genjutsu when the user is preoccupied with the genjutsu. You didn't deliver proof on Obito's technique. You couldn't provide me a reference where it states what technique Obito used on Yagura. So wanting to give that ability to Itachi goes out the window, when you don't know what it is just ridiculous.

      How does Obito's abilities relate to Itachi? Where is the precedent of Itachi controlling a tailed beast? Please, you are grasping straws there.

      Anyways, back in the actual scenario. Having dealt with a few of Menma's masked beasts, Itachi switches tactics, trying to level the playing field. He uses crow clones and fire release to blindside a few beasts. Menma sees this and counters by working together with the remaining beasts. Menma manages to defeat the crow clone, but by now only has three masked beasts remaining.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Instead of watching the anime I suggest you read the Manga. Chapter 260. He never states it doesn't affect the clone. Stop grasping at straws. 1st, Kakashi's clone seen he was paper then was burned to ash (if it didn't trap it, what was this then? LOL was Kakashi's clone day dreaming?). Itachi: "Indeed, you are a skilled Jutsu user. Cause you concealed yourself with that Doton (Earth Release), I didn't see you until it was too late. No wonder... I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu. This was a Kage Bunshin (Shadow Clone)." LOL Where does he state the Shadow Clone wasn't affected? Look at you making more stuff up.

      "If you say they were fooled, then why didn't Sasuke try and stab Itachi in the throat?" Why waste the energy and stab him at all? Answer, he was fooled momentarily.

      "Danzo's sharingan eye was covered, it was clear that it was not active." I'll actually give you that one. Cause you're right on that. Now you're starting to use actual facts. Maybe this debate isn't a lost cause after all.

      "Chiyo's words, multiple allies can overcome sharingan genjutsu when the user is preoccupied with the genjutsu." Your point, in my scenario, Menma is alone.

      "You didn't deliver proof on Obito's technique. You couldn't provide me a reference where it states what technique Obito used on Yagura." I did. Please provide a reference to another Genjutsu Obito has that controls people, other than Genjutsu: Sharingan. If you can't, then that's the jutsu he used. Why? Same reason the wiki has the Kekkei Genkai Manget Release listed as wind and earth. Cause those were the only elements the user had that weren't occupied for another canon nature Kekkei Genkai. If that bothers you, then I suggest using another site. Since this is the wiki, I'm going by this wiki's rules.

      "How does Obito's abilities relate to Itachi? Where is the precedent of Itachi controlling a tailed beast? Please, you are grasping straws there." It's the jutsu that allows the user to control people, tailed beasts, and do various other things. Even if Genjutsu: Sharingan isn't the technique Obito used on Yagura (It is, until proven otherwise just as Magnet Release is the combination of Wind and Earth), it still stated to do all that, and even stated to be able to control a tailed beast inside it's Jinchuriki. Thus, my scenario still works and thus Menma dies, until you can prove Menma and Kurama can both break free from Sharingan: Genjutsu.

        Loading editor
    • @LoneNinja

      This is quite interesting. After a long time I found something new in Naruto.

      While I do admit, Itachi's statement on the clone is anime from what I remember, "No wonder... I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu." can also refer to the clone. Even though I said I'm not gonna argue on genjutsu anymore, evidence trumps everything.

      Ch 260, the clone attacks from the underground and Itachi intercepts the attack. He then proceeds to cast a sharingan genjutsu. A genjutsu sequence plays out. What are the facts? Itachi casts a genjutsu, it appears the clone is caught. In the real world, the clone grabs Itachi, the clone has no visible signs of fatigue, stunning, immobilization, hypnosis or any of that.

      Which means there are three options:

      1) The genjutsu was cast, the clone was affected by it, but instantly broke out, while suffering no ill effects. And grabbed Itachi before he realized.

      2) The genjutsu was cast, the clone experienced the genjutsu, but was not affected by it( similar to Itachi vs Kurenai), was able to push through it's effects and continued to grab Itachi.

      3) The genjutsu was cast, the clone caught Itachi in a genjutsu that showed him what he wanted to see. The clone then proceeded with the plan to grab Itachi.

      Either way you look at it, the clone was still able to proceed and grab Itachi. I think I have just shown that sharingan genjutsu is not as unbeatable as you think. (A clone can push through it lol.)

      Also, If Itachi was momentarily fooled, Sasuke could have stabbed him. Is he not fast? I don't have to prove anything. You have to prove your statements. Which you haven't in this case. You are making up things.

      Look, can we stop with this. Your scenario, is quite lame.

        Loading editor
    • No he was talking to Kakashi. Because the clone did not use Doton. Kakashi did.

      "Indeed, you are a skilled Jutsu user. Cause you concealed yourself with that Doton (Earth Release), I didn't see you until it was too late. No wonder... I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu. This was a Kage Bunshin (Shadow Clone)." /This/ Refers to Shadow Clone. /You/ Refers to Kakashi.

      If he was referring to the Shadow Clone, he would've said "I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu. /You're/ a Kage Bunshin (Shadow Clone)."

      I never claimed the Sharingan: Genjutsu was unstoppable. And it wasn't instant. The Genjutsu was shown. He was trapped in it for a bit to the point that he was nearly burned completely to ash, and Itachi was even talking. That isn't instantaneous. I also never said there was no doubt Menma couldn't break the Genjutsu. All I've been asking you is how does he? You stated, with Kurama's Chakra, which I countered with Genjutsu: Sharingan can control Kurama and prevent Menma from using his reserves. So that means you have to tell me how Menma breaks the Genjutsu without Kurama's reserves.

      Then you have to explain why Itachi is holding still, since in Chapter 15, Kakashi wasn't. Why Itachi wouldn't cut Menma's throat while Menma is trapped in Genjutsu, before he breaks it.

      I don't care if the scenario is lame. Change the fight description to them having prep time if you want them going all out, and having Itachi have his Susanoo out and Menma with his masked beasts.

      My scenario is the most likely to happen since Itachi does this all the time. His first move is almost always a Genjutsu. Besides, you asked for my scenario first. I gave it. It's only right to disprove my scenario and debate it before moving on to yours which was posted after mine.

        Loading editor
    • Itachi easy win. He could use his Tsukiyomi and finish Menma off. Itachi just has more experience and more skill than Menma. Sure Menma is one of the most powerful members of the namikaze clan but compared to Itachi...no its just not a fair fight. Itachi has some of the most powerful genjutsu in the series and has a full susanoo. This fight could last some time and Menma could almost beat Itachi... but in the end Itachis power is just simply greater than Menma's. Good matchup but this one goes to Itachi.

        Loading editor
    • @LoneNinja

      The clone used earth release. It tunneled underground to attack Itachi. Itachi made that comment though, you can't deny it. Look, I've just showed that a clone pushed through Itachi's sharingan genjutsu. It's safe to say Menma can do better. So Menma's throat is not getting slit. Also, please stop giving abilities to Itachi that he doesn't have, it's getting real old.

      In any case, Itachi doesn't know anything about Menma. How does he suddenly know he must control Kurama? I see you giving Itachi prep again. So your scenario is once again ruled out. If you have a problem with this, you have to disprove the clone feat. Until then, Menma can handle sharingan genjutsu.

        Loading editor
    • When Kurenai put Itachi under genjutsu,didn't Itachi use reverse genjutsu and put Kurenai in genjutsu instead?

        Loading editor
    • I think this battle will go in Menma's favor for a variety of reasons. For one, we've seen Obito keep a Perfect Jinchuriki in Genjutsu, something Itachi has never done. People keep saying Itachi will trap Menma in Genjutsu then finish him off, but being that Obito (and by extension Menma because he is being possessed by Obito and having his Sharingan) was able to keep a PJ in Genjutsu for a long time, I dont see how Itachi can counter that, even with his Genjutsu prowess. For all we know he could just as easily keep Itachi in such a genjutsu.

      But that's besides the point. In most ITachi fights, they never allow Itachi to rely on his Ninjutsu, they always jump straight to the Hax like TB and YM and Koto. Why not let them both duke it out with ninjutsu since we dont know what will happen if he uses Non-Kinjutsu Genjutsu on Menma?

      Based on Menma's fighting style, I dont see him giving Itachi the chance to seal him with the TB, being that he is fast on his feet. He has an amazing connection with Kurama to the point that he can manifest the beast outside his body and with the two working together, I dont see Black Kurama falling pray to the Genjutsu like normal Kurama would. Hell, if Menma reflects his Sharinga into Kurama's eyes, Kurama will has access to Kamui as well, which will pose even greater problems for Itachi.

      "Itachi can put him in Genjust and finish him with Totsuka Blade" Well Menma can finish him off by sending him to Kamui's Dimension, spam Spiralling Rings or Great Spiralling Rings, can easily dodge his techniques by sensing the negative intent, can have the Shinigami use his scythe to extract the chakra directly from Itachi's body with a simple swing. Not to mention he countered blows from Naruto's Sage Mode and could increase his own strength.

      "Itachi will then slice his throat" As if Kurama will sit by and let Itachi do so andwon't just heal Menma's throat if it happened.

      When fighting a very skilled opponent, you can't just rely on one field to defeat them. When people pit Madara and Hashirama against each other, they usually assume Madara's Genjutsu won't work on Hashi and I've read this on multiple occasions. Why do they assume this without solid proof? I have no clue, but they do. Yet people assume Menma will automatically fall for Itachi's non-hax genjutsu just because he's Itachi, when Obito has shown an impressive feat of genjutsu use with the standard Genjutsu: Sharingan. And this isn't even including Obito granting Menma use of his other abilities within the Genjutsu World.

      I like Itachi, but Genjutsu and tools alone won't win him this battle when he is working against a tailed beast and a skilled fighter that in base state can compete with a Sage Mode user.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of war

      As im reading the posts im starting to realize your very one sided on this debate.

      Whenever someone brings up solid evidence of Itachi beating Menma you just deny it and act like a total fanboy for Menma.

      A little advice try not being one sided next versus you create.

        Loading editor
    • @AyyynimeBoy

      Certain users bring up false points and twist evidence to fit a certain narrative. I don't stand for such things. I have not denied anything. Similar to @Naruto10647, you fell down the big gaping hole. You could have countered my points or scenario. Instead you chose to call me one sided and throw around the word fanboy.

      You now have lost credibility on this thread. Construct a reasonable counter and take your own advise.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: @AyyynimeBoy

      Certain users bring up false points and twist evidence to fit a certain narrative. I don't stand for such things. I have not denied anything. Similar to @Naruto10647, you fell down the big gaping hole. You could have countered my points or scenario. Instead you chose to call me one sided and throw around the word fanboy.

      You now have lost credibility on this thread. Construct a reasonable counter and take your own advise.

      What makes you think that we don't have solid proof and evidence? I already said my scenario and you didn't counter it. As I said, Itachi had enough strength and speed to be able to be on par with Naruto in Rikudo mode, same Naruto who said he was superior to Sennin mode. Itachi also has Susano'o which was capable of tanking Kirin. An S-class jutusu in it’s own right. He’s also capable of forming it faster than actual lightning, which he did with insanely low chakra reserves. And what about Itachi's explosive clones,in addition to having the Susanoo to protect them from attacks.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of war

      While the point of users brining up fake evidence is clear in almost every versus and I fully agree with you on that. One thing no one has brought up to my knowledge, is that Menma would have to fight blind seeing that if he looked at Itachi, Menma would be trapped in his genjutsu. But like you said this battle will not be won with only genjutsu, and again I agree with that 100%. The thing is Itachi is one of the seven ninja (in the entire world!) to be able to use the full susanoo which could easily keep up with Menmas SM.


      This fight could easily go either way in a split second of battle. Seeing that you gave Menma the abilites of Obitos MS. But with a combination of his Susanoo and TB Itachi could put Menma in a genjutsu, have his Susanoo keep Kuruma busy while Itachi goes in for the kill.

      I would like to see a counter that will make me question this fight and let me put more thought into the subject.

        Loading editor
    • @Naruto10647

      I did. Scroll up, it's there. I countered that "speed feat" of yours. Susanoo did defend Itachi, but after the attack, his cloak was gone and his arm was damaged. So, Kirin got through Susanoo and injured him. But what does this have to do with Menma?

        Loading editor
    • ^ The main purpose of susanoo for this battle is to fight Kuruma and keep him busy so Itachi could put Menma into a genjutsu and finish him off. Basicly susanoo would be used as a diverson to keep kuruma from stopping Itachi kill Menma. If he did not have susanoo this battle would go to Menma...(but he does)

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: @Naruto10647

      I did. Scroll up, it's there. I countered that "speed feat" of yours. Susanoo did defend Itachi, but after the attack, his cloak was gone and his arm was damaged. So, Kirin got through Susanoo and injured him. But what does this have to do with Menma?

      When Sasuke used Kirin on Itachi,he wasn't it in his susano'o. Tell me,how would Menma go through Susano'o as well? Just a reminder,explosive clones would be around Susano'o protecting Itachi.

        Loading editor
    • ^How though? The scenario you have crafted doesn't just appear like that.

      I can agree with your previous post, to a point. Menma doesn't have SM. A few users have brought up that point that you mentioned. I even brought evidence how that can be dealt with. You didn't see that? Anyways, you haven't countered my scenario, (based on your posts I don't think you even read my scenario), so I don't feel the need to counter yours.

      However, if you are willing to have a discussion, then so do I. So, what's your counter?

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^How though? The scenario you have crafted doesn't just appear like that.

      I can agree with your previous post, to a point. Menma doesn't have SM. A few users have brought up that point that you mentioned. I even brought evidence how that can be dealt with. You didn't see that? Anyways, you haven't countered my scenario, (based on your posts I don't think you even read my scenario), so I don't feel the need to counter yours.

      However, if you are willing to have a discussion, then so do I. So, what's your counter?

      What scenario?

        Loading editor
    • ^My Itachi vs Menma scenario.

      Short version: (neglecting sharingan genjutsu) Itachi starts off with kunai that are stopped by Menma. Menma releases the nine masked beasts. A scuffle breaks out, but Itachi uses Amaterasu, crow clones and fire release to defeat all but three masked beasts.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja Of War wrote: ^My Itachi vs Menma scenario.

      May you send it again?

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Never have I gave Itachi an ability he doesn't have? Which ability? Now you have reached the point of a fan arguing over a character he likes, and lying. The moment you said Itachi did not have Genjutsu: Sharingan, you lost the debate. When did you say that? When you said I gave abilities to Itachi he didn't have. However, the only ability I have mentioned to the post you replied to is Genjutsu: Sharingan. Therefore, you lied and said he didn't have it. Thus I can no longer trust anything you say. He does indeed have this jutsu since he is listed as a user in the Databook, and been shown to use it in the Manga.

      Then you say I have to disprove a Clone breaking out of Sharingan: Genjutsu. No I don't. Why? It wasn't instant as you suggest it is, which is a lie. Instant means the moment it happened. Yet, the clone was stuck in the Genjutsu for as long as it's entire body was burned. Sorry but that doesn't fall under the category as instant. In fact, Itachi even spoke, and it was still in Genjutsu while he spoke. So at least a few seconds passed.

      No. Menma cannot do the same until you prove he can. You are the one giving abilities to Menma that he doesn't have. He does not, nor have ever been shown to break Genjutsu instantly.

      Also, just cause Kakashi can break Genjutsu, doesn't mean Menma can. What kind of logic is that? That's like me saying just cause Gai can run non stop for days, so can Itachi. You have to prove Menma can break Genjutsu without Kurama, but you obviously can't which is why you dodge the question, thus Menma loses.

      P.s. "Certain users bring up false points and twist evidence to fit a certain narrative." This is rich coming from a guy claiming Itachi doesn't have Genjutsu: Sharingan and said Kakashi's Clone broke out instantly. We got a case of a pot calling a kettle black, here.

        Loading editor
    • ^If you think I'm referring to sharingan: genjutsu, then you are truly lost. You just made a false point. I'm referring to the genjutsu Obito used to control Yagura that you can't name. You gave that genjutsu to Itachi, even though you can't name it. Now you are trying to seg-way into Sharingan:Genjutsu to cover yourself. That is making up facts. Don't try to put words in my mouth and muddle the truth.

      Stop twisting things to seem right.

      On the clone point, guess you just disregarded my analysis of what transpired. Nothing surprising there considering how 'selective' you are. You disregarded several things, such as the clone using earth release. I didn't say the clone breaking out of the genjutsu was instant, I said it was one of the options.

      Again, you are crafting a narrative here by putting your own spin on what I said. I then said that, despite all the options of what happened, the clone was still able to proceed to grab Itachi, which is true. The clone had no visible signs of incapacitation. The clone didn't even hesitate.

      So yeah, you do have to show why a full powered Menma(with an MS) won't be able to do the same or better.

      Don't come at me with false accusations just to seem right, this is a discussion. If you don't understand ask, say no to ignorance.

        Loading editor
    • "If you think I'm referring to sharingan: genjutsu, then you are truly lost. You just made a false point. I'm referring to the genjutsu Obito used to control Yagura that you can't name. " Where in the post you replied to, did I mention the Genjutsu Yagura was put in? No where. So that wasn't the Genjutsu you were referring to, since I stopped mentioning cause you couldn't accept that Genjutsu was Genjutsu: Sharingan, despite that being the only Genjutsu Obito used. So yes, you referred to Genjutsu: Sharingan, since it was the only technique I mentioned. I didn't even mention the Yagura controlling abilities. Only the abilities Genjutsu; Sharingan is stated to have, check the Databook, Manga, and Wiki.

      So therefore, since it was the only Genjutsu and it's abilities were the only thing I mentioned, you could only be referring to it. Therefore you lied.

      "Stop twisting things to seem right." You're the one grasping at straws and taking things from Itachi and giving Menma abilities he never had. Like Obito's Mangekyo LOL. He never had it. Never did the character Menma use Mangekyo. Obito did though. Obito also possessed Menma's body, sure. But Obito does not equal Menma.

      "On the clone point, guess you just disregarded my analysis of what transpired. Nothing surprising there considering how 'selective' you are. You disregarded several things, such as the clone using earth release. I didn't say the clone breaking out of the genjutsu was instant, I said it was one of the options." Darn straight I'm going to disregard what you said. For the mere fact /If he was referring to the Shadow Clone, he would've said "I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu. /You're/ a Kage Bunshin (Shadow Clone)."/ He wouldn't have went from calling the Shadow clone /you/ to /this/. By saying /this/, it shows that he is talking to someone else, which you disregard. /This/ and /you/ are different identities associated to different things in this instance. It's common English.

      And no I don't have to prove why Menma with the ability to use Mangekyo can't break Genjutsu. Sharingan is never stated to be immune to Genjutsu. That argument is horrible. That's like saying "You have to prove why Sakura can't break Tsukuyomi". That's not how it works. I proved how Itachi can cast Genjutsu on Menma, you don't get to just say he breaks it just because he's Menma. LOL. That's called fanboy logic. I want proof he has the ability to do so. You have to prove why Menma is immune to Genjutsu or can break it, Lol. You also have to prove how Menma even has the knowledge on how he can even use the Mangekyo since it took Kakashi years before he was able to use it, despite unlocking it years prior.

      They're not accusations if those are the things you literally said.

        Loading editor
    • ^No, that's not what I was talking about. You have a bad habit of telling people what they must mean, that must stop. You want to be right by constructing falsities. Don't cry wolf just because things aren't going your way.

      You didn't prove what genjutsu Obito used on Yagura. So yeah, I can deny that Itachi suddenly has this technique. Are you also this late whining about the DP? LOL. Why then did you bother with this thread? Someone's true colors are showing.

      LoneNinja wrote:

      Darn straight I'm going to disregard what you said.

      Everything I said about Kakashi's shadow clone was true. So you are denying the fact that the clone was able to 'push' through the genjutsu and grab Itachi? That part particularly bothers you. Why are you denying this? Again, don't cherry pick things because Itachi is involved.

      Gosh, you are running away with your own version of what I said. I'm saying, if a clone was able to 'push' through sharingan:genjutsu, Mema should be able to do the same or better. Due to him also having an MS and exceptional chakra control (Masked beast point). There is also the issue of the genjutsu maybe not being as strong as you think it is. I'll say it again, the clone was not visibly affected( real world).

      I'm not sure what you mean anymore, since it looks like all you have are false accusations and comparisons that don't make sense. Apparently a genjutsu that a clone can handle can't be handled by someone with similar abilities and exceptional chakra control, in your mind.

      Don't project your frustrations on me. You, like so many others, have fallen down the pit of ignorance, by throwing the word fanboy around. In doing so you have lost credibility on this thread.

      @Naruto10647

      I think I replied with the wrong post to your previous question. First off, the battle won't start with Itachi in Susanoo. There are preliminary stages of the fight. Secondly, why would Itachi have explosive clones around his Susanoo? Can he even? Susanoo requires a lot of chakra. We haven't seen him using any other technique while in Susanoo.

      Thirdly, Menma has a few options. Great-spiraling ring, Kamui for phasing and Kamui for absorption. Also maybe the grim reaper's jutsu would work as well. To get through Susanoo. Please give a scenario after you commented on mine.

        Loading editor
    • 1) Please show me where in the post you replied to, where I mentioned the Genjutsu that Yagura was placed in. If you can't, then why did you mention it when I stopped talking about it? No logic.

      2) Again. I don't need to prove it, since I don't need that Genjutsu. Genjutsu: Sharingan is already stated to have those abilities anyways. Please refer to the wiki page to see for yourself. :]

      3) When have I ever denied the clone pushing through the Genjutsu? I haven't. So why are you putting words in my mouth? Smh. All I stated was that the Clone was caught in the Genjutsu for a brief time. He was affected and there was a time duration. He was turned to paper, burned entirely, and Itachi was talking. /Then/ the clone grabbed Itachi in real life. The Genjutsu was never stated to have time diluting abilities so you can't give it that.

      4) Since the Clone was indeed affected, or that Genjutsu scene would of never been shown, I don't have to go on about this. Naruto proved that Itachi's Genjutsu isn't easy to break. He tried using the methods, Jiraiya, a legendary Sannin, gave him. How can Menma do what he did not? Is he going to use a different method? If so, what method?

      5) What I meant, you don't get to just say Menma breaks the Genjutsu instantly with the logic that he gets to do it cause he's Menma. You need to prove that he has the ability to break a Genjutsu from a high class Genjutsu user like Itachi. Menma is not Kakashi. He does not possess the same experience as Kakashi with Sharingan.

      6) I am neither frustrated or ignorant. If majority of people believe you to be an overly loving fan, then that is how you project yourself. That is no fault of anyone's, other than yours. I have lost no credibility since you are clearly a fan. Are you stating you are not a fan of Menma? Doubtful. Your arguments prove otherwise. The way you hype him up without feats an actual proof of having such abilities (such as being able to break Itachi's Genjutsu, just cause Kakashi can), proves you are an overly loving fan, or really want to win a debate and will do anything to do so, LOL. I'm a simple guy. All I require is proof. So far, you have given me none. I have retracted statements in the past after you have showed me actual proof. I am reasonable. But when I give proof, you twist it like saying "Kakashi was probably never affected by the Genjutsu, the whole Genjutsu thing never really happened" not your exact words, but from what you said, to me, looks like your analysis. How is that not fan logic? You also disregard the fact that Sharingan: Genjutsu's abilities and just state Menma can break the Genjutsu just because. How is that not fan logic? You see how it's hard not to call you a fan, this is how what you type looks to some people, if this is not the case, then you need to clarify.

        Loading editor
    • 1&2) It's because you didn't make a point of distinguishing the two or explaining you were wrong on the first point. You just seg-wayed into sharingan:Genjutsu and acted like you were talking about it all along, to seem right. Claiming you had proof on something you didn't know lol. So yeah, I'm not standing for such behaviour.

      3.1)In my earlier post, I called you out for disregarding my analysis of the entire Kakashi clone scenario. Where I explained everything that happened as it did. Trying to reason why the clone was able to do what it did. In your next post you confirmed that you denied what I said. So no, you can't weasel your way out of that one lol.

      3.2) The clone didn't seem too concerned in the genjutsu, so don't know what you are trying to achieve by bringing that up. Yes, Itachi started talking in the genjutsu, to the clone. Ch 260 confirms this, the bottom panel transitions to Kakashi's clone after Itachi comments how good a jutsu user he is.

      4)Yes you do. There is a precedent for Itachi's sharingan:genjutsu being dealt with easily by a clone. That alone is enough to discredit your point of Itachi winning with sharingan genjutsu only. Naruto is not a good indication of genjutsu strength. Up until that point he didn't experience sharingan genjutsu. And the training he received also calls into question when you consider who taught it to him.

      Yes, Jiraiya, is a Sanin. That don't make him the best teacher of genjutsu or how to deal with it. He himself claimed genjutsu is not his forte. Don't run with the Sanin narrative, I see what you are doing. Also, you are comparing that Naruto to Menma. Which is just laughable. Again, don't craft such narratives. Menma is more comparable to SM Naruto.

      5) If you actually read what I said. After the new evidence, I said Menma could also 'push' through the same way the clone did. The instant part is just you crafting things. Now, here is something. High class genjutsu is in question as I said, or are you denying again? So are you saying due to the clone having the sharingan, that resulting in the clone not being affected by the genjutsu?

      6)Lol, you think just because a majority thinks something is x, it has to be x. Now that's bad logic. No, it wasn't a majority, it was two users, which you are now the third. Yes you have lost credibility just like the others, you could have reasoned, but chose to use fanboy instead. Funny, you talk about proof, but deny actual feats. Ironic.

      Then claim I haven't given proof, when I was talking about actual feats. Again, bad logic. I copied what Itachi said and showed you how he was talking to the clone. But you write that off as fanboy logic. Lol, as I said, you are projecting. In paraphrased words of Itachi, Take a good look at yourself @LoneNinja or you will find yourself in trouble.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Boy someone is getting mad. Getting hostile there buddy. Simmer down.

      1&2) So now you are implying Obito could of used Izanagi or Infinite Tsukyomi to control Yagura? Boy are you grasping for air here. My proof is that Obito only has those two Genjutsus and Genjutsu: Sharingan. So those are the /only/ choices Obito could've used. If you say it isn't or might not be Genjutsu: Sharingan, then you imply it is one of the other two. Unless you're saying Obito might have another Genjutsu even though that isn't stated nor shown, thus means you are making up more facts.

      3) Disregard does not mean to deny. I suggest you look it up in a dictionary. Disregard means to ignore so no one is trying to weasel out of anything. You also keep dodging this "/If he was referring to the Shadow Clone, he would've said "I wouldn't expect /you/ to be affected by the Genjutsu. /You're/ a Kage Bunshin (Shadow Clone)."/ He wouldn't have went from calling the Shadow clone /you/ to /this/. By saying /this/, it shows that he is talking to someone else, which you disregard. /This/ and /you/ are different identities associated to different things in this instance. It's common English." The fact you dodge this, is all I need.

      3.2) He was caught for a brief time is my point. Menma can be as well, and thus get his throat slit.

      4) I can use the fact that he has never experienced Sharingan: Genjutsu argument for Menmas Case, since he also has never been stated to experience it.

      5) Where's your proof he can? Where has it been stated that Menma has any skills whatsoever against Genjutsu? Has it ever been shown Menma being caught in Genjutsu? How do you know he isn't weak to Genjutsu? You don't. All these ifs, buts, might, this, and that, does not work or equal proof.

      6) What actual feats have I denied? Stop getting hurt over a computer screen.

        Loading editor
    • All I see, is a bunch of whining. you both look like you're twisting facts to suit your needs. This vs forum is flawed as hell. It should have a panel of non biased judges and go by actual debate rules. That way only facts can be presented. A mod should come and ban this thread or something. You can see Ninja of War and LoneNinja getting hostile with each other. Both Ninjas wanna out ninja the other.

      From what I am reading though, War you seem incredibly biased, everyone seems to think Itachi wins, with a small amount thinking Menma does. I read the panel in Chapter 260. No way is Itachi talking to Kakashi's clone. But just cause Kakashi's clone can break a Genjutsu doesn't mean Menma can.

      Lone the point that Obito can only have three Genjutsu's is kinda dumb. Kakashi was said to have copied over a thousand jutsu but his jutsu list isn't over a thousand, so you can assume he has more jutsu then the jutsu he has listed.

      A mod should close this thread though, before it gets out of hand. I see name calling. People who get petty over a debate is eww.

      Naruto also makes a good point. I don't think Menma has the capability of getting through a Yata Mirror enhanced Susanoo. Menma's most op attack is his Great Spiralling Ring and I think I've seen a Susano'o survive worst.

        Loading editor
    • @LoneNinja

      Lol, project all you like, it's your coping mechanism.

      1&2) That isn't proof. I asked where in the manga is the genjutsu specifically stated. Since you stated it to be true, provide that evidence. If you don't, then you can't use it as a point.

      3.1) So you ignore my points which reflect feats. Yep, weaseling out is your specialty. He was talking about the technique, he didn't have to use another /you/. The fact that /you/ (lol) think that what /you/ said overrides what I said is hilarious.

      3.2) Yes, he experienced the genjutsu. 'Caught', implies he was affected by the genjutsu, i.e. suffered some negative effects. Which the clone visibly did not. What did Itachi do? Nothing. Itachi said he was too late in the genjutsu already. Menma throat not getting cut.

      4) You can try, but Menma has a MS.

      5) Yes, like all versus threads, there are a lot of ifs, buts etc. That's what a discussion is. From what I've come to realize, you don't want a discussion. You want to say your points, and then somehow think you are the supreme authority on what others say when they criticize it. Your language is quite snobbish and you like to talk down to people.

      When a point with an accompanying feat directly opposes your point. You try and discredit the opposing point by, downplaying, ignoring, and making up your own narrative.

      6) Scroll up, it's all there in my previous posts.

      @JamesDuh

      Nah, haven't been whining or biased. I understand it can seem that way since I have been defending Menma. But if you actually look at my posts, in particular, the ones where I describe my scenario, you'll see what I'm really talking about.

      Ch260, Itachi begins his speech inside the genjutsu. To the clone. Please explain that then. Yes, a clone can push through the genjutsu. Why is it a significant genjutsu then?

      Guess you didn't see my reply to @Naruto10647 also. It's a shame.

        Loading editor
    • Ninja of war. You should re-read yours and Lone's posts. It can be perceived as you both whining. You both have gotten pretty hostile, at least to me. As for the chapter. I see Itachi talk to the clone then stops. The clone then grabs Itachi. Then Itachi goes to speak. The manga panel switches from Itachi to Kakashi as he speaks, implying he is talking to Kakashi not the clone since the Manga doesn't showcase it anymore or it's reaction, which Kakashi replies with an order for Naruto to get Itachi and his Shadow Clone. And I can't be expected to read all your posts War. There's a lot, and most of them are wall texts. I don't have that kind of time. But if you want to restate your counter, I'll be happy to read it and tell you what I think.

        Loading editor
    • @Ninja of War

      Go ahead and deny all you want, that's /your/ coping mechanism.

      There's really no reason to continue with so many off topic discussions. All I gotta say, is you can't prove Menma can break Sharingan: Genjutsu in time before Itachi can cut his throat. If you can simply state it, then I'm done. No need to get all booty hurt. Sharingan: Genjutsu is stated to be able to control a tailed beast within a Jinchuriki, so Kurama's reserves are a no go.

      @JamesDuh

      I was neither hostile, nor whining. If I was, show me where. You are right about the Kakashi statement, and copying a thousand jutsus. I retract that statement.

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh

      I have. I admit, I got side-tracked trying to show him why his point won't work. Hostile? That's a strong word. I called him out on the things he did. Never did I whine.

      Yes, the panel does shift to Kakashi crawling out of the hole. But how does that refer to real Kakashi? Itachi says in the genjutsu that he didn't see the earth release in time. In any case, what's this alternative argument you are trying to say. Itachi saying to Kakashi that he expected his genjutsu not to work on him? How does that explain Itachi going in for genjutsu?

      There is a lot. Yet, you saw fit to judge me based on only what you wanted to read. This is a problem that a few other users also seem to have.

      Would you care for a rundown of the fight after you commented on my scenario?

      Ninja Of War wrote:

      My Itachi vs Menma scenario. Short version: (neglecting sharingan genjutsu) Itachi starts off with kunai that are stopped by Menma. Menma releases the nine masked beasts. A scuffle breaks out, but Itachi uses Amaterasu, crow clones and fire release to defeat all but three masked beasts.


        Loading editor
    • War. The problem with Itachi talking to the Shadow Clone theory that you are saying is that it becomes a contradiction. Since the clone was trapped in Genjutsu for a short amount of time. Sure, the clone pushed through it somehow and broke it. But if he was talking to the clone and said "I wouldn't expect you to be affected" then it becomes a contradiction to what we just witnessed. So it doesn't make sense for him to be talking to the clone. Why does it even matter if he was or not? What does that even have to do with Menma vs Itachi? Anyways, I did judge you off what I read. What else would I judge you on? Not sure what you're trying to say here. And sure, but first can I ask why Itachi is using Amaterasu so early in the fight? I don't think he would use such a jutsu so early, since Itachi doesn't have an Eternal Mangekyo, I don't think he would use his Mangekyo so carelessly, since it would result in him going blind.

      Lone. You were both whining in a way. You guys both got petty and resorted to name calling, he calling you ignorant, you calling him Fanboy. That too me, is whining. That is also a reasonable statement. Do you have a way for Menma to break Itachi's Genjutsu if he should get trapped in it? @War

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh.

      Yes, it does become a contradiction. I'm saying that Itachi was talking to the clone because the clone wasn't affected (note: I'm not saying he didn't experience the genjutsu.) If Itachi was talking to the real Kakashi, why did he try and use genjutsu, if he said Kakashi wouldn't be affected? That to me is your point.

      Again, this instance calls into question the genjutsu that Itachi used. It pokes some holes in the argument of Itachi catching people in genjutsu and winning. That is my point.

      You judge me off everything. Not just a few things you read of me defending Menma. That's not the whole story. I posted the short version of the scenario, it's just highlights. Black Kurama can help Menma out with genjutsu. But as I stated before, if a clone can push through, why can't Menma?

      Furthermore, @LoneNinja confirmed to ignore my points which had supporting feats. So yeah, I called him out on that.

      @LoneNinja

      Yeah, keep on projecting. Keep on ignoring my points. We can all see what you are doing. It's better to have a discussion, than trying to be right all the time.

        Loading editor
    • War. The problem, again, is that the clone was affected. Affected means to be influenced, which means to have an effect. The effect here is that the clone was in a Genjutsu realm for a short time. That is being affected. So if he stated to the clone "You weren't affected" then it is a contradiction that doesn't make sense. So there's no way he was talking to the clone for this very reason. I don't see why that's hard to grasp. I can't judge you off everything dude. As I said, I don't have the time to read everything you post since there is indeed a lot. And what do you even mean by judge you? Judge your point? Or you, yourself? Cause I don't think I judged any of your points except the ones you have provided since I joined the debate. Also can you answer Lone's question instead of trying to be hostile with each other? That's not how debates should work. :I

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh

      The clone experienced the genjutsu that's for sure. Affected, not so much. The contradiction here is apparent to me, that's why it's hard to grasp your interpretation. I'm also trying to indicate that, if you just read the posts where I defend Menma, then of course you will think I only want Menma to win. Which is not the case.

      I don't feel the need to answer Lone's question again. I have already answered it. Lone posted that he chose to ignore my points, so yeah, can't have a discussion there.

      Are you going to give a scenario though?

        Loading editor
    • War. Affected is to be influenced by. Influenced by means to have an effect. The effect here was Kakashi's clone was in the Genjutsu for a small amount of time. And if the contradiction is apparent to you, why go with that theory? If you theorize that Itachi is talking to a clone but the theory contradicts itself, that would prove the theory wrong. I still don't understand why this Manga Chapter even matters. I don't see you defending Itachi anywhere dude. So you definitely want Menma to win. And no I'm not giving a scenario, I'm looking at points and basing the winner off the most facts. I also have not seen you answer Lone's question as I skimmed through the posts. Can you quote yourself, where you answered it? It will help me see your side of things.

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh

      JamesDuh wrote: The effect here was Kakashi's clone was in the Genjutsu for a small amount of time.

      That may be true, but Itachi wasn't able to capitalize on that effect. So it wasn't that effective.

      JamesDuh wrote: And if the contradiction is apparent to you, why go with that theory? I still don't understand why this Manga Chapter even matters.

      No, your interpretation has the contradiction in it, not mine. That's why I don't understand it. The clone managed to overcome Itachi's genjutsu, quite easily. Itachi wasn't able to counter it. So, it speaks to the effectiveness of Itachi's genjutsu in general. That's the point.

      JamesDuh wrote: I don't see you defending Itachi anywhere dude. So you definitely want Menma to win.

      Once again you are being selective. Most of my posts with Lone have been trying to show why the fight won't end with genjutsu. That's what I've been showing the whole time. Never have I stated that Menma would win. Defending Itachi? Against what? I've been trying to move on from the genjutsu point. Please try to understand where I'm coming from.

      JamesDuh wrote: And no I'm not giving a scenario, I'm looking at points and basing the winner off the most facts. I also have not seen you answer Lone's question as I skimmed through the posts. Can you quote yourself, where you answered it? It will help me see your side of things.

      That's quite unfortunate. I was looking forward to your scenario. In any case, if you are not going to give one, I don't see the point of continuing. I don't know how objective you can be to be honest.

      I've got no beef with you or anyone here. Just can't understand why certain things are taken the way users want them, instead of how they are. I might have not been clear on my points, but I've tried to clarify them. I think that if we all try to understand what the post is trying to mean, then we can have an actual discussion.

        Loading editor
    • War. I don't see a contradiction in my post man. All I said is he can't be talking to the clone because then it contradicts itself. Because it was affected by the Genjutsu for a small amount of time. But he said it didn't affect the person he was talking to. Where's the contradiction other than that? I don't think I ever said the clone never overcame the Genjutsu. I actually agreed with you. I think you might be confusing me with Lone. I don't want to provide a scenario just in case i miss certain points. Since I don't have enough knowledge on Menma to give an accurate one. As long as you don't come at me like you came at Lone, we'll be fine. I won't attack you for your points, so go ahead and say them. I just want to see your side of things. That's why I'm asking to see a counter to Lone's question. You obviously know Menma, so I would like to know his capabilities so I myself can come to a scenario of how this fight will go.

        Loading editor
    • Vinuth123 wrote:

      Vinuth123 wrote: TSUKUYOMI is enough for itachi to win.

      dudes I said it 3 times

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh

      Ninja Of War wrote:

      If Itachi was talking to the real Kakashi, why did he try and use genjutsu, if he said Kakashi wouldn't be affected? That to me is your point.

      ^That is your contradiction. Honestly, it's not acceptable.

      I never came at you. Note, please don't come at me with accusations of being biased towards Menma, when I am not.

      @Vinuth123

      Care to give a rundown?

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh. You're wasting your time lol. He is a fanboy, the fact that only he seems to think Itachi was talking to Kakashi's clone, is priceless and doesn't make sense. You even came to the same conclusion as me.

        Loading editor
    • War. "If Itachi was talking to the real Kakashi, why did he try and use genjutsu, if he said Kakashi wouldn't be affected? That to me is your point." He used Genjutsu before he was talking? He wasn't talking to Kakashi, then used Genjutsu dude. He literally cast the Genjutsu. The clone was in the Genjutsu. Itachi started to talk to the clone. He stopped talking. Clone grabs him. Itachi begins talking to the real Kakashi who reveals himself. I can see now where you got confused. However, it's impossible for him to be talking to the clone in that instance for two very reasons, the clone is no longer shown but Kakashi himself as Itachi speaks, implying he is talking to Kakashi. And secondly, he stated to the person he was talking to that they weren't caught in the Genjutsu. The statements showcase two subjects, a person, and an object. object being a clone, person being Kakashi.

      Lone. Quit insulting War. I don't care if you agree with me. Do not act childish.

        Loading editor
    • @JamesDuh

      I can now understand you better. In ch260, the clone is still visible in the same panel. Let's look at the facts, Itachi clearly states that he wouldn't expect (insert Kakashi/clone) to be affected by the genjutsu. Your interpretation doesn't supersede mine, since Itachi wouldn't try to use a technique that he knows won't work on Kakashi. Please explain why your interpretation does.

      @LoneNinja

      It's clear that you don't want a discussion. It's also quite unfortunate that you think insults enhance your 'points'. Your use of the word 'fanboy' is once again incorrect. This casts you in a bad light. Please refrain from posting here if you are not gonna add anything to this discussion.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message