Seelentau wrote: Having Hashirama's cells doesn't mean having Ashura's power. Ashura moved on after Hashirama dies, while Hashirama's cells were taken from his body after he died. If they were taken from his body while he was alive - like Madara did - it would probably make Yamato (and the others) some kind of successor, yes.
If Naruto is not immune to the genjutus it would be stupid because the only reason sasuke is immune is because he has half the power of the sage Naruto has the other half so it would stand to reason he is immune not to mention Naruto has all the tailed beasts in him and a jinchuuriki who is friends with his tailed beast is immune to genjutsu
The fact that Yamato has WR is an indicator that he has Hashirama's cells, nothing else. WR was never connected to Ashura at all. Sasuke is immune to the Genjutsu because of his Rinnegan. If Naruto was immune, Sasuke would've let him go help the others.
None of the Edo Tensei Hokage are caught in the genjutsu, likely something to do with their status. It's nothing to do with having the Sage's power.
Seelentau wrote: The fact that Yamato has WR is an indicator that he has Hashirama's cells, nothing else. WR was never connected to Ashura at all. Sasuke is immune to the Genjutsu because of his Rinnegan. If Naruto was immune, Sasuke would've let him go help the others.
I am sorry but you are wrong. as a successor of Ashura Hashirama had an abnormally strong life force and that is solely the reason he could use wood release. no one else in the Senju clan was capable of doing it. Ashura's powers are bound to his successors DNA. thats why Madara has the Rinnegan(because he has not only Indra but Ashura's chakra bound to his body) so far the only people to have wood release had Hashirama's cells implanted in them which so far they have implied the chakra of the user is bound to their cells ie Hashirama is a successor of Ashura then it must mean his power stems from Ashura's
Ashura's power no longer rests in Hashirama, nor does it rest in his cells. According to Hagoromo, Hashirama and Madara were born with Ashura and Indra's powers respectively. When Madara took Hashirama's cells it gave him the Sage's powers. At this point Sasuke and Naruto are the only ones with the power of the Sage's sons.
@OP, sorry, but you are wrong while Seel and Soul are right.
I ain't wrong, that's not in the concept of being me.
Also, what Soul reaper said.
Soul reaper wrote: Ashura's power no longer rests in Hashirama, nor does it rest in his cells. According to Hagoromo, Hashirama and Madara were born with Ashura and Indra's powers respectively. When Madara took Hashirama's cells it gave him the Sage's powers. At this point Sasuke and Naruto are the only ones with the power of the Sage's sons.
Hagoromo said he gained Ashura's powers when he gained access to the Rinnegan he did not say that he no longer had Indra and Ashura's powers in him if that is the case he would not sense himself in Sasuke.
since the power of Indra and Ashura combined is Hagoromo's powers it must stand to reason he still has Indra and Ashura's powers bound to him. also if sasuke and Naruto were the only ones who had Indra and Ashura in them then Edo Tensei Hashirama would not be as powerful as he is. because his powers come from Ashura. so again your wrong.
The chakra got REINCARNATED into different individuals over time. Meaning when that person died, the chakra was cloned to another body. Henceforth when they were edo tensei summoned they kept there asura/indra chakra. lets look at the facts, the dna and cells make the chakra/kekkei genkei. Yamato's dna is the same as Hashirama's being a human clone, therefore by extension he does have Asuras Chakra. Remember how special Hashirama's dna is with all that life force stuff and what not?? that was because it was Asuras chakra originally. Every person with Hashi's dna has pieces of Asuras chakra.
ItachiWasAHero wrote: The chakra got REINCARNATED into different individuals over time. Meaning when that person died, the chakra was cloned to another body. Henceforth when they were edo tensei summoned they kept there asura/indra chakra. lets look at the facts, the dna and cells make the chakra/kekkei genkei. Yamato's dna is the same as Hashirama's being a human clone, therefore by extension he does have Asuras Chakra. Remember how special Hashirama's dna is with all that life force stuff and what not?? that was because it was Asuras chakra originally. Every person with Hashi's dna has pieces of Asuras chakra.
Exactly but the correct term is not Reincarnated but succeeded the actual translation of the Japanese never says Reincarnation