So, it's been months now sense the old discussion kinda ended. I'm curious as to what will happen, can we just spam create game jutsu articles or will something else be done?
So, it's been months now sense the old discussion kinda ended. I'm curious as to what will happen, can we just spam create game jutsu articles or will something else be done?
The thing that had been most agreed upon is to create centralized articles for the bulk of video game jutsu. What had not been agreed upon is by what we would make these articles. Some people (Snapper or Simant if I'm not mistaken) wanted to make them by game, I wanted to make them by character. While per game has a logic behind it, it would create far too much duplicated content,which is why I wanted to make these articles by character.
I agree that they should be made by game because if they were made by character then too many pages would exist for it. In these pages will each jutsu be written like the others, with a picture, class, type and such. Another big problem that I think it would make is the large number of pages that will get deleted.
I agree with Omnibender, per-character is better and more organised. Doing it by character is more easier to query and add to the SMW Browser page, whereas per game will likely be very long and load slowly.
SuperSajuuk wrote: I agree with Omnibender, per-character is better and more organised. Doing it by character is more easier to query and add to the SMW Browser page, whereas per game will likely be very long and load slowly.
You guys keep going back and forth with different ideas. if one has been decided upon then could you move it into effect?
Munchvtec wrote: You guys keep going back and forth with different ideas. if one has been decided upon then could you move it into effect?
Nothing has been decided whatsoever. It's up to the community to come to an agreement on this. Considering the lack of people who work on game based articles on the wiki, it's hard to get a consensus.
Munchvtec wrote: can we just spam create game jutsu articles or will something else be done?
Asking for permission to "spam" the wiki is not the best way to characterize what you want to do.
Omnibender wrote: While per game has a logic behind it, it would create far too much duplicated content,which is why I wanted to make these articles by character.
I still don't feel duplication is an issue. Besides, certain game-only techniques are shared between characters, so some level of redundancy is unavoidable.
SuperSajuuk wrote: Doing it by character is more easier to query and add to the SMW Browser page
I don't know about that, or even the advantages if true.
SuperSajuuk wrote: whereas per game will likely be very long and load slowly.
I disagree with this more comfortably. Some games will have size issues, sure, but so will some characters; Naruto's been in every game, right? So his subpage will be comparatively enormous.